Understanding the Risks of Private Equity Investments: No Guarantees, Only Opportunities

Many potential investors inquire whether their investment in C2 Legacy Buyout has any form of guarantee. While it is understandable that investors want assurances, it is essential to understand the fundamental nature of investment risk and the legal limitations surrounding private equity funds, mainly when they are eligible for programs like the Portuguese Golden Visa.    

1) The Reality of Investment Risk    

All investments, by nature, come with some degree of risk. No investment, whether private equity, real estate, or government bonds, can be entirely risk-free. Market conditions change, economic shocks occur, and businesses face unforeseen challenges. As a private equity fund, C2 Legacy Buyout is no exception. It offers opportunities but comes with inherent risks that can only be eliminated partially.    

2) No Risk-Free Golden Visa Investments    

In Portugal, investment funds such as C2 Legacy Buyout can be eligible for the Portuguese Golden Visa. However, Golden Visa-eligible investments must be made into equity instruments by law. Equity, by its nature, means that the investor is taking on ownership of part of a company or a fund’s underlying assets. This implies that the investor’s returns are tied to the performance of these investments, making it impossible to offer a completely risk-free structure while complying with legal requirements.    

Any investment that claims to offer Golden Visa eligibility while promising no risk should be treated with skepticism, as this would indicate a potential misunderstanding—or even deliberate misrepresentation—of the legal framework and the nature of equity investment.    

3) The law forbids Guaranteed Buybacks    

Another common misconception is that fund managers can provide guaranteed buybacks for private equity investments, promising to repurchase shares at a predetermined price or when the investor desires. This practice is, in fact, illegal in Portugal and most jurisdictions regulating private equity.    

Under the law, private equity investments must reflect the assets' underlying risk. Offering a guaranteed buyback would violate this principle and distort the true nature of the investment. For this reason, any entity claiming to provide such guarantees is potentially committing a financial crime, and investors should exercise extreme caution when presented with such claims.    

4) The Risk of Buyback Even if it Were Allowed: Counterparty Risk    

Even if guaranteed buybacks were legally permissible (which they are not), this would introduce another risk element: counterparty risk.    

What is counterparty risk?    

Counterparty risk refers to the risk that the party providing the guarantee (in this case, the entity promising to buy back shares) may be unable to fulfill its obligations. But, if a fund or investment manager promises to buy back shares, the investor relies on that entity’s financial stability. If the entity cannot deliver when investors collectively decide to exit—say, during an economic downturn or liquidity crisis—there may not be enough capital to cover all the promised buybacks.    

This means that even if a buyback option were allowed, it would not eliminate the investment's inherent risk. The risk shifts from market risk (the risk of the assets losing value) to counterparty risk (the risk that the entity guaranteeing the buyback might default).    

In scenarios where multiple investors demand a buyback simultaneously, such as in a financial downturn, this could lead to a liquidity crisis for the entity, making it impossible for all investors to recover their funds. Ultimately, any form of guarantee in private equity is illusory because counterparty risk always persists.    

Advice: Minimizing Risk Through Thorough Due Diligence    

The best strategy for investors seeking to minimize risk, especially in Golden Visa investments in Portugal, is to conduct thorough due diligence on the fund manager. Key factors to evaluate include:    

• Long History: A long-standing presence in the market demonstrates resilience and adaptability.    

• Proven Track Record: A history of successful investments and exits shows the fund manager’s ability to navigate different market conditions.    

• Professional Team: A dedicated, multidisciplinary team with sector-specific knowledge ensures that experts make investment decisions.    

• Specific Competence: The manager’s expertise in areas like succession planning, buyouts, and capital constraints can significantly affect outcomes.    

• Assets Under Management (AUM): A larger AUM typically indicates greater experience and ability to manage and allocate significant capital effectively.    

‍

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article reflects my personal views and is not intended as financial advice or an investment solicitation. All readers are strongly encouraged to consult with a professional financial advisor to assess their circumstances and risk tolerance before making investment decisions.    

‍